It’s a trailer for the four-part documentary that I’m currently working on called The Pope and The Devil, on which I investigate the controversial role of Pope Pius XII during the Second World War. Thanks to the production company being granted exclusive access to the Vatican’s almost fabled Secret Archive, it is now possible to give a truly informed account of the Pope’s actions in the 1930s and 1940s – which his critics say were too sympathetic towards Nazism, while his defenders maintain that the Pope did his best to walk a tricky line.
The series, which will be aired on Discovery and Viasat (and hopefully many other channels worldwide) is currently still in production, and I shall shortly be heading to Munich and Berlin to film more segments.
In the meantime, as well as the trailer, please also enjoy some of these exclusive behind-the-scenes shots from the filming in the Vatican. It was a real privilege to be able to get into the Secret Archive, and it’s great to be able to share these pictures with subscribers to Walt’s World! (By the way, do check out that door bell…)
Walt's World is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
Wonderful. Fingers crossed there are still some juicy things in there. Question. As a historian, looking at archives, and wanting to follow the evidence, how do you deal with the issue that archivists might have only kept documents supporting the party line / a positive spin? Without having to speculate on what’s missing? Seems a thorny issue…thanks.
This is the HUGE problem with private archives. When I look at family papers deposited in university libraries, or indeed at the documents of the 'Nazi' bishop Alois Hudal at the German Seminary in Rome, you just know that they are often holding something back. And if it's private, there's not a lot you can do. Public archives you can issue FOI requests. But you can't do that with the Vatican. My impression is that they are playing it fair and just want to get the issue of Pius XII resolved in some way.
Heavens above! What a treat this production is going to be. To say I'm envious is the understatement of the decade. For an historian turned theologian (retired, got bored, changed discipline) I would love some insights into what the Catholic hierarchy actually think. You're very fortunate Guy & the doorbell looks like something out of the 60s secret service!
This looks brilliant! A definite must watch, I’ve long been fascinated with with the history of the Vatican and the “secret archives.” I’m keeping my fingers crossed that it’ll be shown on a platform I have access too. I saw that you actually got to go outside to do your talking head thing, makes a change from seeing you in a dark room 😊!
That looks like it would be worth watching. A couple of years ago, perhaps more, in the space of a week I heard two authors opine on The Pope’s complicity or otherwise. One suggested he turned a blind eye, knew what was going but did little to help. The other was kinder but still critical. The truth probably lies in between, as I’m sure you will reveal.
Fascinating stuff - I’m not aware of any previous, in-depth investigations, so I very much look forward to watching the finished documentary in due course. Just watching your series on the Nazi Post-War Plan and it’s utterly brilliant.
I have visited Berlin and Munich and found them to be amazing cities, drenched in history - enjoy your trip(s)!
I think ever since reading the DaVinci code, I’ve been fascinated by the archives and what secrets really are held within. Oh my God Guy. I don’t really do envy, but on this occasion, I’ll allow myself a bit. Looking forward to it muchly! Good job they didn’t have HP printers back then because half the stuff would be missing. 😬
I’m torn between wanting to dive straight into those archives myself & being slightly disappointed that the room didn’t look like something out of Hogwarts...
Will keep an eye out for this either way, it’s not something I know that much about.
I remember your Crowdcast Talk on Hunting Evil and you mentioned some of the "Goodies" you found in the Archivo Segreto Vaticano on that occasion. Think I will need a whole carafe of Negronis for this Documentary.
Enjoy Munich and especially Berlin which is one of my favourite City Breaks and enjoy a glass of Paulaner or 2.
It would be possible to spend centuries going through that, wonder what secrets are still hidden there? It may come across as overly cynical, but I regard the Vatican as the world's first megacorporation in a way. That such a significant amount of human history is kept in one place, the scale of it must be, ahem, biblical.
It looks like a gripping watch, I sincerely hope I'll be able to catch it
Wonderful. Fingers crossed there are still some juicy things in there. Question. As a historian, looking at archives, and wanting to follow the evidence, how do you deal with the issue that archivists might have only kept documents supporting the party line / a positive spin? Without having to speculate on what’s missing? Seems a thorny issue…thanks.
This is the HUGE problem with private archives. When I look at family papers deposited in university libraries, or indeed at the documents of the 'Nazi' bishop Alois Hudal at the German Seminary in Rome, you just know that they are often holding something back. And if it's private, there's not a lot you can do. Public archives you can issue FOI requests. But you can't do that with the Vatican. My impression is that they are playing it fair and just want to get the issue of Pius XII resolved in some way.
Heavens above! What a treat this production is going to be. To say I'm envious is the understatement of the decade. For an historian turned theologian (retired, got bored, changed discipline) I would love some insights into what the Catholic hierarchy actually think. You're very fortunate Guy & the doorbell looks like something out of the 60s secret service!
This looks brilliant! A definite must watch, I’ve long been fascinated with with the history of the Vatican and the “secret archives.” I’m keeping my fingers crossed that it’ll be shown on a platform I have access too. I saw that you actually got to go outside to do your talking head thing, makes a change from seeing you in a dark room 😊!
Thanks Julie! Will of course let you know when and where it's on!
That looks like it would be worth watching. A couple of years ago, perhaps more, in the space of a week I heard two authors opine on The Pope’s complicity or otherwise. One suggested he turned a blind eye, knew what was going but did little to help. The other was kinder but still critical. The truth probably lies in between, as I’m sure you will reveal.
Looking forward to, and new revelations....
Fascinating stuff - I’m not aware of any previous, in-depth investigations, so I very much look forward to watching the finished documentary in due course. Just watching your series on the Nazi Post-War Plan and it’s utterly brilliant.
I have visited Berlin and Munich and found them to be amazing cities, drenched in history - enjoy your trip(s)!
Thank you for your kind words Beverley! Much appreciated!
I think ever since reading the DaVinci code, I’ve been fascinated by the archives and what secrets really are held within. Oh my God Guy. I don’t really do envy, but on this occasion, I’ll allow myself a bit. Looking forward to it muchly! Good job they didn’t have HP printers back then because half the stuff would be missing. 😬
Hahahaha! Not even the Pope could get an HP printer to function...
That does look interesting I’ll give that a watch when it’s released for sure
Thank you!
Very cool. And all infallible...
I’m torn between wanting to dive straight into those archives myself & being slightly disappointed that the room didn’t look like something out of Hogwarts...
Will keep an eye out for this either way, it’s not something I know that much about.
I remember your Crowdcast Talk on Hunting Evil and you mentioned some of the "Goodies" you found in the Archivo Segreto Vaticano on that occasion. Think I will need a whole carafe of Negronis for this Documentary.
Enjoy Munich and especially Berlin which is one of my favourite City Breaks and enjoy a glass of Paulaner or 2.
I will indeed Simon - thank you!
Negronis…
It would be possible to spend centuries going through that, wonder what secrets are still hidden there? It may come across as overly cynical, but I regard the Vatican as the world's first megacorporation in a way. That such a significant amount of human history is kept in one place, the scale of it must be, ahem, biblical.
It looks like a gripping watch, I sincerely hope I'll be able to catch it
I'll be sure to let you and everyone know when it airs!
WOW!! archives by the lorry load and wonder how many have never ever been opened! Looking forward to the series.